Register now to get rid of these ads!

Technical Broken Camshaft

Discussion in 'The Hokey Ass Message Board' started by L79_Acadian, Jul 31, 2023.

  1. pirate
    Joined: Jun 29, 2006
    Posts: 1,180

    pirate
    Member
    from Alabama

    Well I’m not an expert but have been involved in the manufacture of camshafts. This cam was manufactured from either a casting or forging and not billet. A crack could have started and/or propagated as the result of a straightening process during manufacture. The crack maybe the result of poor heat treatment/quenching and went undetected. The other possibility looking at the lobes closely is “grinding burn” resulting in surface cracks due to insufficient coolant during final grinding of cam profile. At least a couple lobes look suspicious. Cams I was involved in were all Magna-fluxed as a part of final inspection.
    IMG_1932.jpeg
    Of course a lot of factors are unknown such as manufacturing process, heat treatment, cam material, post manufacturing quality procedures, etc. Not pointing the finger at anyone but in my opinion a camshaft never turning a rpm in a running engine shouldn’t fail unless mishandled or damaged after manufacture. My opinion your mileage may vary!
     
  2. 55 Ford Gasser
    Joined: Jul 7, 2011
    Posts: 726

    55 Ford Gasser
    Member

    Sorry, but I've got to tell this story.
    IHC Bus already in shop, I was given work order to do tune-up (1987-DoverAFB). Change plugs,points, etc. Would not start, distributor 180 out, okay, how'd that happen. Pull distributor out, re-install, still not starting. Pull v/covers, only front rockers moving, broken camshaft. New camshaft comes in, different mechanic goes to install, but can't figure out how to remove rest of camshaft so I take a look, with timing cover off I can see a broken rod laying against the camshaft. So, that's why the original work order had a second line item 'install driveshaft.' The person that originally wrote the wo said he drove bus around compound and it needed a tune-up. I am still wondering how he drove it. Lol.
     
  3. That is bizarre ... I can't imagine a cam breaking right through a lobe like that unless it was due to a manufacturing defect. Only other possibility (in my mind) is the cam was dropped at some point. No way (again ... in my mind) that it broke like that just from turning it in the block, even if something obstructed its ability to turn. Basically this, if the cam was well made and not dropped, I honestly can't see it breaking where it broke, just from turning it in the block, obstruction or not.

    It looks like you are in Canada and Isky isn't. Are you sure Isky has it in their possession yet? (delivery confirmation). I'd say, as others have too, give them a bit of time ... there may be more involved in the checking process than simply opening the package and eyeballing it.
     
    Deuces, winduptoy and 427 sleeper like this.
  4. winduptoy
    Joined: Feb 19, 2013
    Posts: 3,651

    winduptoy
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    wow that looks like a cam blank problem...after close inspection I don't know if I would have even installed it in the first place but I do lots of things I shouldn't too trusting in the manufacturer/supplier
    the porosity is what concerns me
    we will see how others check in
    it's a shame you are having to go thru this but better in your garage turning it by hand than out there flying down the road somewhere in Hong Kong, Switzerland
     
  5. Russco
    Joined: Nov 27, 2005
    Posts: 4,330

    Russco
    Member
    from Central IL

    I was just wondering I drill mine for that too but I have had an old race Flathead that had keyed lifters in it. I was just wondering if someone is still selling those.
     
  6. triumph 1
    Joined: Feb 9, 2011
    Posts: 599

    triumph 1
    Member

    My guess would be that it was dropped or mishandled in shipping that caused it to crack most of the way in that spot.
     
    bobss396 and AccurateMike like this.
  7. Kevin Ardinger
    Joined: Aug 31, 2019
    Posts: 943

    Kevin Ardinger
    Member

    If you watch Stormin Bonneville, one episode he’s building the engine and the cam is broken in half in the box. No mention of manufacturer that I remember. Sounds like a fairly common problem. Good grief!
     
    seb fontana likes this.
  8. Pete1
    Joined: Aug 23, 2004
    Posts: 2,261

    Pete1
    Member
    from Wa.

    Yes, I make them and furnish several cam grinds that use them.
     
  9. I'm not the most experienced cam installer by a long shot.......
    But I agree with the first paragraph above. That looks to me like an unfinished, raw, "blank" cam. Shouldn't the lobes be ground to a profile with a higher polish than that?
    If there was no clearance because of oversize lobes, that could snap it like a chicken bone in a single rotation.
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2023
    winduptoy likes this.
  10. Fordors
    Joined: Sep 22, 2016
    Posts: 6,051

    Fordors
    Member

    That finish treatment is know as Parkerizing, it’s done in an acid bath to put small craters on the lobes to hold oil to aid the cam to lifter break in.
     
    winduptoy and The Shift Wizard like this.
  11. Okay. thanks. I've only heard the term but I'm not familiar with how it looks.
     
  12. Pete1
    Joined: Aug 23, 2004
    Posts: 2,261

    Pete1
    Member
    from Wa.

    That cam has all of the appearances of being welded. The left lobe on the heel and the right one on the toe. Notice the differences in color at the weld parting line. Notice the small pits at various locations. Welded lobes if done properly will be as good or better than original. Isky had ones in the early days he called "Hardface Overlays". They stood up very well.
    There are several methods for welding cams both for racing and plain damage repair. Most work well.
     
  13. L79_Acadian
    Joined: Oct 3, 2006
    Posts: 95

    L79_Acadian
    Member
    from canada

    Welded lobes, well if they were, then they were done by ISKENDERIAN. I open the cam out of the box and plastic bag,before I installed it into the flathead
     
  14. L79_Acadian
    Joined: Oct 3, 2006
    Posts: 95

    L79_Acadian
    Member
    from canada

    Well still waiting for a reply from Nolan at ISKENDERIAN cams. First he couldn't find the cam, then found it, and now its been a few weeks and still no reply on what is happening with the camshaft. That is the first and last ISKENDERIAN cam shaft I will ever buy. Their customer service is poor to say the least. It doesn't take but a minute to reply to someone's email
     
    bchctybob likes this.
  15. alanp561
    Joined: Oct 1, 2017
    Posts: 5,142

    alanp561
    ALLIANCE MEMBER

    Thunderbird and orange juice, Silver Satin and cherry Kool-Aid, a quart of Ripple for $.69, a six pack of Brew 102 for $.79. My liver is still in shock:eek::eek:
     
    Tman likes this.
  16. Budget36
    Joined: Nov 29, 2014
    Posts: 14,770

    Budget36
    Member

    Is there cell charges for calling the US from Canada? If so I could see the use of email, but maybe a phone call is in order by now?
     
    SS327 and Deuces like this.
  17. RAK
    Joined: Jul 15, 2011
    Posts: 163

    RAK
    Member

    About 15+ years ago I received a brand new Max1 cam from a vendor in Florida (that is no longer in business) and it was broken in half (I figured from shipping abuse). I called the vendor and they sent a new one immediately without any drama. Did you buy yours through a vendor or the manufacturer?
     
  18. 05snopro440
    Joined: Mar 15, 2011
    Posts: 2,326

    05snopro440
    Member

    If it's Nolan Jamora who is their COO, he's a pretty busy guy.

    I would expect a response before now too, but you were already writing them off when they only just received the cam. The tone of your communication with them may tune their urgency as well.
     
    ottoman, 427 sleeper and ekimneirbo like this.
  19. G-son
    Joined: Dec 19, 2012
    Posts: 1,451

    G-son
    Member
    from Sweden

    Ugh, phonecalls. Some of us would be much happier if we had gone straight from the telegraph to text messaging, without ever inventing the phone. The only possible upside of phonecalls it that they don't automatically leave evidence of exactly what was said - which is also one of the downsides, when you tend to forget things.
    A mail you can easily go back and read again, as many times as you like, and reply to whenever you have the time. Although some people don't get to replying at all, but that isn't any fault of the mail, that's a problem with the person.
     
    bchctybob, seb fontana and Algoma56 like this.
  20. ekimneirbo
    Joined: Apr 29, 2017
    Posts: 4,917

    ekimneirbo

    I bought all the parts to assemble a new bed for a 56 Chevy truck from LMC. When I test fit them together, the right step wouldn't fit. It was completely wrong. It would need a pie cut and welding to even bolt in place. I contacted them and sent pictures showing the problem. They said they would look into it. Several months went by........then a new one showed up and it fit just right.

    I think sometimes maybe it takes a while to resolve a problem. Tooling changes and stuff.
    With the cam, maybe they got a bad bunch of cams and have to go back to their source for resolution rather than send another defective cam to you. Yes, a phone call would be nice and it doesn't help when you are being held up waiting for the part.

    On the other hand, I had Comp Cams lie to me about the availabilty of a catalog camshaft promising delivery in 3 times in 6 months and then admitting they didn't have any cam cores for it and weren't even trying to get any because it wasn't as popular as Chevys. Summit normally stocked this cam and had sold out. Comp was still offering it for sale a year later at a much increased price and still not delivering. I bought a Howards and they delivered pretty much when they said they would.
     
    bchctybob and alanp561 like this.
  21. Based on the date this thread came out "last Friday" would have been July 28th ... surely you've heard back from them by now right???

    Interested in hearing the outcome ...
     
  22. L79_Acadian
    Joined: Oct 3, 2006
    Posts: 95

    L79_Acadian
    Member
    from canada

    Still nothing, not even a email.
    Not a happy customer, thats for sure
     
    bchctybob and seb fontana like this.
  23. I just had absolutely pathetic customer service from Bell Canada (over the course of a couple of days and multiple lies on their end) ... horrible. Nowadays that is pretty much expected when your only possible company contact is some call center on the other side of the world where the employees can outright lie with no chance of being disciplined/fired or even identified ... in the case of Isky, that is NOT the case. If it's out being sonic tested or whatever, the least they could do would be to keep you informed. At this point it almost seems like they're hoping you'll just go away (based on their lack of response).

    Pretty sad ...
     
    Last edited: Sep 20, 2023
    seb fontana likes this.
  24. L79_Acadian
    Joined: Oct 3, 2006
    Posts: 95

    L79_Acadian
    Member
    from canada

    Poor customer service for sure. I have a few cars, and I will never ever buy a Isky camshaft again. Any camshaft except Iskendarian cams.
     
  25. pirate
    Joined: Jun 29, 2006
    Posts: 1,180

    pirate
    Member
    from Alabama

    I guess it’s been six weeks or so was the broken cam issue ever resolved?
     
    Truckdoctor Andy likes this.
  26. ekimneirbo
    Joined: Apr 29, 2017
    Posts: 4,917

    ekimneirbo

    I have noticed on a certain TV show featuring some high profile/high dollar "street racers" that a lot of them wear the Isky Cams logo on their shirts. Must be doing something right.
     
  27. gene-koning
    Joined: Oct 28, 2016
    Posts: 4,848

    gene-koning
    Member

    Selling shirts is much different then selling camshafts, or at least I would hope.

    Want a bunch of street racers to wear your shirts? Drop off a box of shirts at their next meet, the next time you see them, everyone will be wearing one of your shirts.
     
    bchctybob, SS327, X38 and 2 others like this.
  28. stubbsrodandcustom
    Joined: Dec 28, 2010
    Posts: 2,526

    stubbsrodandcustom
    ALLIANCE MEMBER
    from Spring tx

    Man, the Old English was my favorite! haha
     
    Budget36 likes this.
  29. stubbsrodandcustom
    Joined: Dec 28, 2010
    Posts: 2,526

    stubbsrodandcustom
    ALLIANCE MEMBER
    from Spring tx

    Wait till you try to deal with Comp Cams! You thought Isky customer service was bad..... Comp is a whole new level last time I dealt with them.

    Do yourself a solid, buy a regrind next time!
     
    ekimneirbo and winduptoy like this.
  30. 05snopro440
    Joined: Mar 15, 2011
    Posts: 2,326

    05snopro440
    Member

    Those guys wearing brand shirts on racing TV shows aren't wearing them by accident. Those are the sponsors that support them. Isky has camshafts in a lot of those fast cars on those shows, at drag and drive events, etc.
     
    ekimneirbo likes this.

Share This Page

Register now to get rid of these ads!

Archive

Copyright © 1995-2021 The Jalopy Journal: Steal our stuff, we'll kick your teeth in. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy.

Atomic Industry
Forum software by XenForo™ ©2010-2014 XenForo Ltd.