This is an original, unrestored, never repainted tack strip on a `32 5 window. Body is dark green. Tack strip looks to be black.
I bought a tack strip from UPAC for my 5W and had it powder coated satin black. Matches the black vinyl top perfectly and suits the Commercial Blue paint.
Another thing to consider is that the sealing rubber is black and will blend perfectly with a black or satin black tack strip, not so with body colored one.