Register now to get rid of these ads!

Firestones out of round!

Discussion in 'The Hokey Ass Message Board' started by rc32tx, Jul 3, 2007.

  1. rc32tx
    Joined: Dec 12, 2006
    Posts: 152

    rc32tx
    Member

    Just got a pair of 550-16 Firestones mounted and balanced though they're out of round. Does anyone know of a place here in Texas that can fix 'em? Zero miles on the tires. Also my Ford 16x4" wheels are wobbling back and forth on the computer balancer. Should I just get new Wheel Vintiques?

    Thanks,

    rc
     
  2. JimA
    Joined: Apr 1, 2001
    Posts: 4,795

    JimA
    BANNED

    I got new wheels (from wheel vintique after my originals were wobbly as hell) and had the tires (same ones as yours) SHAVED round (not cheap). I had far less problem with the dirt track fronts as they are made in a better mold.
     
  3. Boones
    Joined: Mar 4, 2001
    Posts: 9,689

    Boones
    Member
    from Kent, Wa

    I had to have all 4 of mine shaved round..
     
  4. Nimrod
    Joined: Dec 13, 2003
    Posts: 856

    Nimrod
    Member

    I've had better luck with the ribbed dirt trackers too. It's funny that the tires marked "for display purposes only" are the only ones that seem to drive well.

    -Jeff
     
  5. brandon
    Joined: Jul 19, 2002
    Posts: 6,382

    brandon
    Member

    i just finished mounting up some 5.60 15 firestones....bubble balanced them ....those things rode and drove like a new car ...then it started getting a little shake.....pulled in the drive way , went in the house ....kid comes in holding 2 of the weights i just put on .....:rolleyes: still trying to figure out how they stayed on the car somewhere for over a mile....oh well time for stick ons or silicone...brandon:D
     
  6. modernbeat
    Joined: Jul 2, 2001
    Posts: 1,310

    modernbeat
    Member
    from Dallas, TX

    Strouhal tire can shave tires round. They do it for bigrig trucks all the time. There's a location south of Houston on 288 that has the equipment.

    http://www.strouhaltire.com/
     
  7. 1931S/X
    Joined: Apr 5, 2007
    Posts: 667

    1931S/X
    Member
    from nj

    is it only the smaller sizes that are out of round? sounds liek a normal thing?
     
  8. Rusty
    Joined: Mar 4, 2004
    Posts: 9,487

    Rusty
    Member

    I have bever had a problem with Firestones or BF goodrich. I would try the stick on weights. I have heard of it done. You will probably have to go to the southern side of the tracks to ne of the southern tire shops. If you can find a shop that cutts whitewalls they should be able to shave them too, hope this helps

    Rusty
     
  9. Kevin Lee
    Joined: Nov 12, 2001
    Posts: 7,676

    Kevin Lee
    Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    Firestone dirt track fronts, and 750x16 rears. Mounted on really nice, straight '35 wires. Balanced road force style. (you should search this) Zero problems.

    Question: How do you know for certain your tires are out of round when they are mounted on "wobbly" wheels?
     
  10. JimA
    Joined: Apr 1, 2001
    Posts: 4,795

    JimA
    BANNED

    Most of them seem to be pretty sketchy- isn't a problem on the old stockers that top out at a bouncy 60mph, but hot rods shake all to hell at 75-plus. And this is working with a good new SO-CAL ch***is. It was normal to have tires shaved round before radials came out. Now the molds are 50-60 years older so think about it.

    And please don't take this a sour note- I will do whatever it takes to run Coker tires as bias-plys are the ONLY look I will ever love. All my trucks (5 of them) have some form of tire from Coker.
     
  11. tunglegubbin
    Joined: Feb 1, 2002
    Posts: 344

    tunglegubbin
    Member

    "And please don't take this a sour note- I will do whatever it takes to run Coker tires as bias-plys are the ONLY look I will ever love"

    The King is naked, can't you people see that. I also appreciate the fact that Coker makes it possible for us to get these tires but there are something wrong with these tires. Corners have been cut somewhere. The "there is nothing wrong with our tires"-approach is really bad customer service.

    Road force balancing finds the weakest/lowest point of the tire which in turn is combined with highest point of the rim.
    It will only help if you have an out of round rim to balance against.
    Doing it on cast/machined wheels is a waste of time.

    Shaving tires are also a waste of time because you do it a near 0 rpm. The out of round at standstill is minimal compared to what happens at 75mph.

    The problem with the Firestones is that the cord buildup is too soft and uneven. The centrifugal force makes them grow at speed and they don't grow evenly. That's why tire pressure, alignment and any type of shaving or balancing won't work.

    A friend recently solved the problem simply by buying Dunlops.
     
  12. zibo
    Joined: Mar 17, 2002
    Posts: 2,361

    zibo
    Member
    from dago ca

    I'd like to try the Excelsiors by coker for the fronts.
    They looked good on a 32 roadster at pomona,
    and may have better roundness.
    tp
     
  13. hot rod pro
    Joined: Jun 1, 2005
    Posts: 2,710

    hot rod pro
    Member
    from spring tx.

    i use A-1 wheel (281 376-9477) in spring.they can shave them,then balance them on your car.



    -danny
     
  14. OldsGuy
    Joined: Aug 12, 2005
    Posts: 425

    OldsGuy
    Member

    Next time someone bags on a guy for running radials on his car I am going to post a link to this thread........
     
  15. raven
    Joined: Aug 19, 2002
    Posts: 4,707

    raven
    Member

    I have new ribbed Firestones and they are out of round too.
    r
     

  16. For sure. Nuff said. But back in the day there was a tire store in town that would true your tires.
     
  17. roddinron
    Joined: May 24, 2006
    Posts: 2,676

    roddinron
    Member

    It almost seems to be a tradition with Firestone. My first new car was a 69 Camaro and it came with Firestone tires, all four needed to be shaved to get them round. Most tire dealers could do it back then since it was a pretty common problem with bias ply tire.
    I can truthfully say, that over the years, I've never owned a good firestone tire.
     
  18. cuznbrucie
    Joined: May 1, 2005
    Posts: 2,567

    cuznbrucie
    Member

    I am running the Coker dirt trackers on the front of my Deuce and my p***enger tire rides nice while the driver's side feels like it's an octagon when you get above 55-60 mph.........

    I may have an out of round tire here too.......and I don't have a clue where to get it trued.....South Jersey.....

    Anybody got a recommendation for a tire service place who can do it?

    Brucie
     
  19. Kevin Lee
    Joined: Nov 12, 2001
    Posts: 7,676

    Kevin Lee
    Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    I have a question about some of these out of round tires. Where were they before you took them to the shop to be balanced? Is it possible they were on your car in mock up phase? Ever notice how a bias ply is flat spotted after being parked for a while - but rounds out after a few revolutions? I don't know - just throwing it out as one possible scenario.

    Basically we are dealing with cars built in garages out of mostly mismatched and scavenged parts - even the So-Cal ch***is. (just a bit bigger garage) So when a car has a problem I have a hard time with others blaming something like a particular tire or a wheel or steering box or whatever when there are so many variables at play. Variables that the person replying couldn't know. Variables that cannot be controlled by the manufacturer.

    Now... I HAD PROBLEMS when I first got on the road with my tires. My car was bouncing all over the place at around 55 or 60. Crazy wobbles and shakes and wierd harmonics. Had them RFV balanced and added shocks and everything has been fine since. I believe Nosurf was having problems... until he lowered his tire pressure and added shocks? (novel idea? :) ) Metalshapes car rules. It has 'Stones and I have ridden in it. It was fast as hell and not rough at all - no arguing he knows how to set up a ch***is. (and I'm not saying So-Cal doesn't) And the person who started this thread (rc32tx) hasn't answered my wobbly wheel question yet.

    Also: And take note that I do not know these things so I am ***uming those who posted them do. But I thought I would bring them back up for some clarification.

    1) posted by tunglegubbin: "The problem with the Firestones is that the cord buildup is too soft and uneven."

    How did you find this out? Cut a tire apart or something?

    2) posted by JimA: Now the molds are 50-60 years older so think about it.

    Are they really using original molds? And I'm thinking... and wondering how would a mold go bad? Interesting to think about... I don't even know what a tire mold is made of.

    I know raven61 is having problems with his ribbed fronts. Out of round and shaking and whatnot. I would be willing - if he was - to put his wheels and tires on my car and take it for a drive to see what happens. And if there were problems on my car as well, we could then take the wheels and tires to a guy I work with for RFV balancing and report results. Could be a very interesting and helpful post I think. You out there raven?
     
  20. Junkyard Jan
    Joined: Jan 7, 2005
    Posts: 738

    Junkyard Jan
    Member Emeritus

    Being that Wall Speedway, an asphalt oval track shouldn't be far from you, I'd ask who shaves tires at a circle track oriented speed shop. Someone there should know. Sporty cars and stock cars which are required to race on street tires have their skins shaved to a minimum tread depth to prevent tire overheating and make them faster.

    Jan
     
  21. raven
    Joined: Aug 19, 2002
    Posts: 4,707

    raven
    Member

    "You out there raven?"

    You're on.
    Name the place and time and I'll bring my 'stones.
    Oh and thanks.
    r
     
  22. JimA
    Joined: Apr 1, 2001
    Posts: 4,795

    JimA
    BANNED

    I did a story on it in Rod & Custom. Worked with a guy who has been on call to the top Bonneville and Indy teams for the last 40-plus years for wheel and tire balancing. He first showed me how out of round the brand new tires were- NO flat spots, they are just molded that way. He shaved the tires round (just as they did for decades before radials)- then he balanced the wheels and tires on his machine with his patented gyro balancing method- THEN spun them on the car and showed how much vibration was still left in the entire spinning m*** with a perfectly shaved round and balanced wheel & tire. The final step was to balance the wheels and tires ON the car and once they were balanced there was absolutely no visible shake in the car as he spun them (up to 90 mph on his machine). This was not voodoo or a one time chance encounter as I cleared the story with Corky Coker himself because I did NOT want to imply that his product was defective (still don't), just was showing a way to make them better.

    Not sure about the vintage on the molds, but when vintage tires started making a comeback there were made in the original Firestone molds in Australia. The thing about the old molds was something the tire guy mentioned to me as he fixed the tires. I know he does a handful of hot rods with fresh bias-plys EVERY week for guys that really want to drive their cars.
     
  23. tunglegubbin
    Joined: Feb 1, 2002
    Posts: 344

    tunglegubbin
    Member

    No, just my conclusion based on their behaviour.
    The problems only occur at relatively high speed.
    The tire throw you see at 80mph is abt 1".
    At standstill there is less than 1/16".
    The cord is what keeps the tire together, if the cord is even the growth would be the same all around the tire.

    Ever notice how flat you can pack a Firestone?
    It is more or less a flat package when you get it, whereas other brands have their shape even unmounted.
     
  24. Kevin Lee
    Joined: Nov 12, 2001
    Posts: 7,676

    Kevin Lee
    Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    Huh... Thanks Jim. Interesting. So the tires had been shaved and balanced (by his method) and still had vibration. (mild or extreme?) Then he rebalanced them on the car and they were good.

    I've never seen tires balanced on the car. I've heard of it and always ***umed it was done with the wheel in the air and the advantage was to include the drum or disc in the balancing process. But maybe I'm wrong and it's done with the weight of the car on the tire? Either way I guess what matters is it works.

    All I really know is my own experience and so far it has been all good. I'm anxious to see how this deal with raven's tires plays out.

    tunglegubbin: If you're stilll checking this out I'm still interested to hear where your information came from as well.
     
  25. Kevin Lee
    Joined: Nov 12, 2001
    Posts: 7,676

    Kevin Lee
    Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    Thanks.
     
  26. HOTRODRUBBER
    Joined: Aug 27, 2005
    Posts: 769

    HOTRODRUBBER
    Member

    Shaving tires are also a waste of time because you do it a near 0 rpm. The out of round at standstill is minimal compared to what happens at 75mph.

    The centrifugal force makes them grow at speed and they don't grow evenly. That's why tire pressure, alignment and any type of shaving or balancing won't work.

    Old Dad has had 40 years in the Heavy Truck Tire Industry. Spent a major part of it with Bandag. When shaving Heavy Truck tires they were never true'd cold. The truck was driven to generate heat in the Nylon casing.Then the truck was driven in to the shop and jacked up on all for corners to help eliminate any flat spotting. This was done very quickly to help aid in truing of the tire in its natural form.Nylon tires change there original shape after thier first heat cycle.This practice has since been forgoten in most "TRUCK" tire shops who mostly deal with" Radial" tires. Now he could be completely full of **** but I doubt it.

    Cody
     
  27. rc32tx
    Joined: Dec 12, 2006
    Posts: 152

    rc32tx
    Member

    The wheels looked alright when I had them checked out by a local tire shop. However, when I had the 550's mounted and computer balanced at Discount Tire, I could see them spinning out of round and wobbling back and forth. I'll have the 550's mounted on Wheel Vintiques as soon as the car is ready to run.
     
  28. JimA
    Joined: Apr 1, 2001
    Posts: 4,795

    JimA
    BANNED

    My stupidity- read it wrong without the quotes.
     
  29. JimA
    Joined: Apr 1, 2001
    Posts: 4,795

    JimA
    BANNED

    That's the experience I had when he balanced them first on the machine- then again on the car (because of the drums Kevin) spinning them hot up to 90mph.
     
  30. Ryan
    Joined: Jan 2, 1995
    Posts: 22,902

    Ryan
    ADMINISTRATOR
    Staff Member

    He wasn't shaving tires for Indy teams as that is illegal... and has been since the early 60's...
     

Share This Page

Register now to get rid of these ads!

Archive

Copyright © 1995-2021 The Jalopy Journal: Steal our stuff, we'll kick your teeth in. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy.

Atomic Industry
Forum software by XenForo™ ©2010-2014 XenForo Ltd.