Register now to get rid of these ads!

Water/Methanol injection Tech request.

Discussion in 'The Hokey Ass Message Board' started by metalshapes, Apr 3, 2010.

  1. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    Also known as ADI.

    This technology has been around since WWII, where it was used on supercharged fighter planes.

    And later on Turbo Corvairs, etc...

    I've been reading up on it, and one sentence that keeps coming up is,
    "Many water injection systems use a mixture of water and alcohol (approximately 50/50), with trace amounts of water-soluble oil"

    I guess Wiki and the other sites are all copying this sentence from eachother.

    But I havent been able to find out exactly what kind of water-soluble oil they are talking about.

    I found some code for a BP product that was used in 1944 by the Brits, but it has been discontinued.

    Something must have replaced it...



    So what is it?

    And where can it be found?
     
    Last edited: Apr 3, 2010
  2. with.disdain
    Joined: Apr 10, 2009
    Posts: 29

    with.disdain
    Member

    A "fuel lubricant" for methanol fueled engines may be what you want. You might want to talk to the guys at Klotz. I know of some people using their fuel lube in race engines.

    http://www.klotzlube.com/techsheet.asp?ID=51&submit2=View

    Plus, they advertise its "racy scent," so, you know, how can you go wrong?

    Brian
     
  3. KrisKustomPaint
    Joined: Apr 20, 2007
    Posts: 1,107

    KrisKustomPaint
    Member

    "water-soluble oil"
    sounds contradictory, but wtf do I know.
     
  4. 29nash
    Joined: Nov 6, 2008
    Posts: 4,542

    29nash
    BANNED
    from colorado

    It's oil that's emulsified so it will mix with water, it's purpose was to lubricate the mechanicals in the ADI system, pump, valves, etc. One way to emulsify oil is to hydrogenate it. The purpose for using alcohol in the mixture was merely to keep it from freezing, more practical than heating the water injection systems at sub-freezing temperatures. Which, of course is true at al***udes above 10 to 12 thousand feet or thereabouts.



    Edit; Pure water gave more power than a mix, but due to operational requirements the ADI fluid had to have an antifreeze component. We did tests with PW R4360-59B in 1956 with different ratios of water/alcohol, and using torquemeter readout it was determined that the higher the water ratio, the higher the torque gain was, when running on ADI.
     
    Last edited: Apr 4, 2010
  5. mart3406
    Joined: May 31, 2009
    Posts: 3,055

    mart3406
    Member
    from Canada

    ----------------------------
    Not quite true. The water cools the charge both in the intake
    tract and inside the cylinder when it vapoprizes - but the methanol
    also contributes quite a bit of cooling due to it's own very high latent
    heat of evaporation. In addition to contributing substantially to the
    cooling effect, the alcohol also acts a fual - an naturaly high-octane,
    slow-burning, oxygen bearing fuel at that - so it also adds some
    power. If the purpose of the methonol was only as an anti-freeze,
    you would'nt use it anywhere near as high as a 50% concentration,
    even in high al***ude aircraft and in summertime automotive
    applications you wouldn't use it all.

    Mart3406
    ===================================
     
    Last edited: Apr 3, 2010
  6. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    That is pretty much the Info I have found sofar.

    The Methanol definately has a advantage even here on the ground in hot and sunnny Arizona.:D

    I built a home brewed system, and it works well.

    But I'm interested in the oil, because I already had to remove my wastegate once to free it up again due to the extra moisture...


    What is it called?

    Brand name if possible...

    Where do I buy some?

    If anybody can help me with that Info, that would be great.


    Thanks guys...:)
     
  7. Piston Farmer
    Joined: Aug 6, 2009
    Posts: 672

    Piston Farmer
    Member

    What about the oil you use in your A/C system? like PAG and ESTER oils? They hold water in your a/c system. don't know how that would work going through your engine though.....
     
  8. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal

    most of your modern water/methanol injection systems don't need any kind of lubrication. in fact, most of the shurflo pumps have epdm valves in them and will fail if any kind of petroleum product is flowed through them.

    fwiw you can use bean oil if you're dead set on needing some kind of lube. although the truth of the matter is that you don't.
     
  9. Da Tinman
    Joined: Dec 29, 2005
    Posts: 4,222

    Da Tinman
    Member

    Wonder if you could use the top lube/fragrance we mix with methanol in the altered?

    cheap and readily available if it would work
     
  10. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal

    Mart definitely hit the nail on the head. If you're going to inject anything why not inject more gas? Well running excessively rich to cool and control combustion to prevent detonation is basically wasting fuel. AFR's richer than 11.5:1 are needed in most cases but power increase is very minimal. Water alone definitely has a power gain but in every case I've seen (and I've seen a lot) the more methanol you have the more power you make. You can only inject so much water before you induce a misfire condition. Running a water/methanol mix allows you to inject more and have even better intake air charge cooling plus detonation control without misfires. Methanol burns cool and clean and it has twice the latent heat that gasoline does. Adding in more fuel via methanol will always make more power than using just water alone.

    WWII airplane engines aren't really operated the same way a forced induction auto engine is.
     
  11. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal

    also, anything petroleum based isn't going to want to mix with water.
     
  12. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    OK, that pretty much answers my questions.

    If the oil was only added to keep the pumps, etc, alive.
    And if its obsolete and not needed for my system, I'm not going to worry about it.

    ( besides... I realised I made a error in my thinking
    The wastegate is on the hot side of the engine, after the combustion chamber.
    Any oil going into the inlet side wont be oil by the time it gets there...)


    Thanks for the Info guys.


    But some interesting things were mentioned...

    I've seen graphs of tests that were done with 100% water, 50/50% water/ methanol, 60/40% methanol/ water, and 100% methanol.
    ( old tests, probably done for airplanes )
    I'll have to see if I can find them again...


    And I've read in other places, that you cant really over feed a engine ( on boost and at RPM )
    I guess hydrolocking it would be a limit...


    But can you overdo it?

    Is there a point where you take too much heat out of the combustion chamber?

    Or wash away too much of the oil film on the cylinder walls?
     
  13. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal

    yes you can technically over inject too much water/methanol but the chance of hydrolock is nil. it'll misfire waaaay before you could ever hurt anything.

    in most cases your water/methanol to fuel ratio is 10-20% (high boost and high heat applications can take 25%-30%) which isn't very much. well you know that you could easily run 10% more fuel and never even think once about washing down the cylinder walls so introducing 10% more of a different kind of fluid (which is in vapor form by time it gets into the combustion chamber) shouldn't wash down the cylinder walls either.

    if you think about it, there is about 10 times more fuel present in the combustion chamber as there is water/methanol. if wash down was going to happen wouldn't it happen with the fluid that you have more of?

    anyways it's late and i'm tired so i'm rambling but no you won't wash down the cylinders. water/methanol injection is pretty much stupid proof and safe on any motor. btw i don't disclose this much but i'm the product development engineer in charge of this product line. let me know if you have any other questions.
     
  14. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member


    Cool...

    Thank you very much for all the Info.

    I may have some more questions later.:D
     
  15. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    BTW, I did have it to the point of misfiring...

    ( moderately high RPM, no load so little or no boost, 50/50 mix )

    But I've toned down the system a bit since then.
     
  16. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal

    ah well you found your misfire threshold. either decrease your overall flow rate or increase the methanol concentration (more fuel means more of the fluid is combustible so more fluid can be injected). is your system on/off or is it progressively controlled? what type of vehicle? what type of forced induction? how much boost? intercooled? details on how your injection system is setup?
     
  17. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    On/Off, but it is two stage.

    Boost controlled by two Hobbs Switches reading the manifold pressure.

    I use a nitrous plate as as a injector, but maybe the secondary side ( the one that was supposed to flow the nitous ) lets too much through?
    ( secondary side is off right now, but I think I'll hook it back up, coming in at a higher pressure)

    The nitrous plate is sandwiched beween the intake manifold and the Accel adaptor ( on the pressure side )

    2775 Pound car( including driver ) with a 351W.

    Vintage Accel Draw Through Turbo.

    8PSI wastegate

    850Holley

    No intercooler.

    I can set the pressure of the W/M , and I have played with pressures of 12 PSI to 20 PSI sofar.
    ( once set they stay at that pressure untill I adjust it to a different setting )

    10A 029 s.jpg
     
    Last edited: Apr 4, 2010
  18. Muttley
    Joined: Nov 30, 2003
    Posts: 18,501

    Muttley
    Member

    I saw an article about this in an old Super Stock Magazine I was flipping through a while back. I'll see if I can find it again and scan it for you.
     
  19. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    Cool..

    Thanks.:)
     
  20. claymore
    Joined: Feb 21, 2009
    Posts: 896

    claymore
    BANNED

    Cheap way out is to use winter windshield washer fluid that comes in the gallon bottles and is available in every Wally mart if you run out in some backwoods area.
     
  21. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    Yep, I've heard that too.

    How does that compare to the 50/50 Distilled water/Methanol mix I'm using now?
     
  22. Truckedup
    Joined: Jul 25, 2006
    Posts: 4,660

    Truckedup
    Member

    This is my actual experience as a hobbyist mechanic. I used a water/methanol injection system(ADI) on the 302 GMC in my 37 Chevy truck.The engine was detonating at full throttle around 3000 rpm.This engine isn't supercharged,the system had a digital controller witha lot of tuning for how long and how much was injected.
    I was told and read these systems are very effective on supercharged engines and not so effective on non supercharged. Some "experts" also told me the water and or alcohol injected can ruin piston rings and that sorta **** from the oil being washed off the cylinder walls.
    Anyways,the system kinda worked,it never completey eliminated the detonation.Might have been because of the deign of the inline intake with a single central injection point. I used Denatured alcohol and water.Denatured alcohol is mostly Ethanol with a little Methanol added to make it non drinkable.I noticed a light power increase,most likely from the reduction in detonation.
    After ****ing around alot I decided the system wasn't what I expected,a cure all.I spent time messing with the spark advance curve and carburetor hi speed jetting to get the detonation under control.
    I have a lot of WW2 aircraft technical ****.In some cases the ADI injection rate was about 10-20 percent of the gasoline flow.Some of the engines were running upwards of 30 psi boost.Nothing is mentioned off any added lubricant,but that might be a given that isn't mentioned.Plus the fighter aircraft using hi boost had engine lives of less than 400 hours anyways.
     
  23. GMC BUBBA
    Joined: Jun 15, 2006
    Posts: 3,420

    GMC BUBBA
    Member Emeritus

    This is what i ran on my 409 64 chevrolet for 11 years or so ( before i traded the car). Uses windshield solvent , allows only a mist or vapor to enter the engine and stopped spark knock ...works great..... air tex and others made these in a kit form.........i actuall have a few of the kits from the sixtys but this is a home made version..........
     

    Attached Files:

  24. Mr Shapes
    Some of the fellas use windshield washer fluid in them. The lubricant is already in there as it is the same type of pump and at least up here most windshield washer fluid has methanol in it to keep it from freezing.
     
  25. Alex, I am sure you have talked to ElP about this? He is kinda guiding me on a future project. I am going to run a Snow system more than likely.
     
  26. mart3406
    Joined: May 31, 2009
    Posts: 3,055

    mart3406
    Member
    from Canada

    Caution! - Beware of 'Isopropyl' Alcohol!

    Just a word of caution, re using windshield
    washer fluid or any other pre-mixed 'store
    bought' alcohol-containing fluid to inject as
    an anti-detonation fluid in an engine. Make
    absolutely sure that any pre-mixed fluid you
    buy intended for some other use, actually
    contains methyl alcohol (- ie -methanol).
    Some compounds that you buy may contain
    either ethyl aloohol (- ie - 'ethanol' or beverage
    alcohol) or Isopropyl alcohol (which is a****
    other things, commonly sold as 'rubbing
    alcohol' and sometimes used as a medical
    disinfectant, solvent, cleaning fluid additive
    or anti-freeze compound) It may also be
    blended with other types of alcohol - sometimes
    with ethanol in order to 'denature[it, to render
    it undrinkable. You especially want to avoid
    anything containing any amount of isopropyl
    alcohol. if you're going to inject it into your
    engine. Ethanol, if you can get it in pure enough
    form will work ok -just not quite as well as methanol
    - because compared to methanol, it has a slightly
    lower latet heat of evaporation, so it provides less
    of a cooling effect, and has a slightly lower inheirant
    octane rating than methanol. But by itself, ethanol,
    will at least not hurt anything - it's just less effective
    and you need more of it, than methanol. Isopropyl
    acohol however, is a whole other story. It has a very
    low inherant octane rating and using it will actually
    induce detonation rather than prevent it! During WWII,
    there's a story about a fleet of new Hawker Typhoon
    ground attack aircraft using water-alcohol injection
    that suddenly started suffering a rash of sudden and
    catastrophic engine faiures. Engineers were rushed
    out from Britain to discover the cause of the failures
    but where mystified at first, because they coiuld find
    nothing wrong with the engines themselves. Likewise,
    the fuel was checked and found to be up to spec as
    well. Finally the problem was traced down to a
    particular batch of ADI fluid that had been shipped to
    the unit. The formulation for the fluid specified a 50-50
    mix of distilled water and "denatured alcohol"
    (denatured , allegedly to keep pilots and ground crew
    from drinking the stuff!). At the time, "denatured"
    alcohol was either ethanol, cut with with methanol to
    render it poisonous and therefore undrinkable , or
    straight methanol. However, due to a shortage of
    methanol, the company producing the ADI fluid -
    without knowing that it would cause any problems,
    unwittingly subsi***uted isopropyl alcohol for methanol
    as the denaturing agent When the aircraft started using
    this particular batch of ADI fluid, the engines suddenly
    started experiencing severe detonation, leading to sudden
    catostophic engine failure and the loss of several almost
    new aircraft. The problem was eventualy traced to the
    use of isopropyl alcohol in the ADI fluid and when the fluid
    was switched for the proper fluid containing methanol, the
    failures stopped. If you're going to buy any fluid not
    originally intended to be injected into an engine as an
    anti-detonation fluid , make sure you know exactly what
    type or types of alcohol (and what other chemicals as
    well) that the blend actually contains The safest thing to
    do is simply to always blend your own fluid by buying
    guarenteed straight methanol and mixing it with distilled
    water. That way you know *exactly* what you're injecting
    into your engine.

    Mart3406
    =============================
     
  27. metalshapes
    Joined: Nov 18, 2002
    Posts: 11,130

    metalshapes
    Member

    Good Information...

    Thank you.

    I'll stick to mixing my own.
     
  28. JohnEvans
    Joined: Apr 13, 2008
    Posts: 4,883

    JohnEvans
    Member
    from Phoenix AZ

    As far as "Soluble oil " goes the stuff sold as cooling system anti-rust is usually soluble oil. S/O is also used in machining as a lube/coolant.
     
  29. Muttley
    Joined: Nov 30, 2003
    Posts: 18,501

    Muttley
    Member

    This article is from the July '65 issue of Drag Strip:

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
     
  30. Beef Stew
    Joined: Oct 9, 2008
    Posts: 1,253

    Beef Stew
    Member
    from So Cal


    Neat setup. I think the mix of parts you're working with is leaving a lot on the table as far as usable power gains go. I see a couple things holding you back... low pressure, low atomization, unknown flow rate, etc. Shoot me an email tomorrow and I'll get you the nitty-gritty details: nstewart@aempower.com
     

Share This Page

Register now to get rid of these ads!

Archive

Copyright © 1995-2021 The Jalopy Journal: Steal our stuff, we'll kick your teeth in. Terms of Service. Privacy Policy.

Atomic Industry
Forum software by XenForo™ ©2010-2014 XenForo Ltd.