How much whould you pay for this?

thirty five hundred around here, would be about right. i'd grab it up for 2, if u can.

 

$1500-1800 here.

 

around here it would be it the 3500 ranger for sure. id offer two if i was you

 

Some comps for you:

Two years ago I sold my dad's '51 3100 parts truck for $2,000. Straight with minimal rust but poor paint; 6 cyl ran OK, but no title, no interior and a few missing parts. (It's the white one pictured below.)

Last year I sold dad's driver '51 3100 for $5,500. 6 cyl running gear and brakes were first rate, newer tires, cheapie resell-red paint job and crummy interior.

Here's the kicker: Three years ago I found a stalled project where the owner just wanted OUT. '51 3100 with shiny fresh paint, good running 327, 9-inch rear, front discs and tilt column. All the heavy lifting done and just needed finishing up. $3,000. (OK, those deals are hard to find, but they're out there.)

As to the truck in the original post, in my opinion $1,500 is great, $2,000 is fair, $2,500 is OK.

Here's the one I sold for 2K: